हैरी पॉटर

इस प्रश्न का उत्तर दो

हैरी पॉटर सवाल

Why could Harry see thestrals after Cedric's death when in fact he didn't actually see the moment when Petigrew took his life?

"A blast of green light blazed throug Harry's eyelids, and he heard something heavy fall to the ground beside him; the pain in his scar reached such a pitch that he retched, and then it diminished; terrified of what he was about to see, he opened his stinging eyes. Cedric was lying spread-eagled on the ground beside him. He was dead."
 hurryharry posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
next question »

हैरी पॉटर जवाब

Book-Freak said:
I think it's और the fact that he was there when it happened, he heard it happen, he saw the body, and he understood death for the first time that leads to him seeing thestrals
 select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Yes, that.
Emseeem posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
nagini10 said:
when they say आप have too "see" death it doesnt literally mean see it happen.
 select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Ok, then why couldn't he see them before since he was also present at his parent's death?
hurryharry posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
^because a one-year-old doesn't understand death.
ArcticWolf posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
No because the death didn't sink in.The death has to sink in to see threstrals.
superhpfan394 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
Jenna4093 said:
Because आप see thestrals once you've seen death, and then accept that persons death. Harry hasn't yet accepted Cedric's death, which is implied in the 5th book when Dudley says that he hears Harry having dreams and he says things about how Cedric shouldn't die. But once Harry has accepted Cedric's death, he can see the thestrals.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
I'm sorry but the book clearly says SEE not ACCEPT so your argument is pointless
hurryharry posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
J.K. Rowling कहा in a interview that आप must see someone die, and accept the death.
Jenna4093 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
Hiding 2 comments... click to show.
*
But this interview with J.K. Rowling isn't: link
Jenna4093 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
lynn52 said:
He was told he could see them because he had been touched द्वारा death, and, of course, he was touched द्वारा his parents' deaths.
 select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
How thick are you? Really
hurryharry posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
^You really need to chill out...
ArcticWolf posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
snusnu13 said:
Actually this is a very good point. Harry didn't actually SEE Cedric's death since his eyes were shut. Hmm, this is one of those "wtf" moments I think.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Exactly! Finally someone who sees reason!
hurryharry posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
Flickerflame said:
The phrase "see death" is metaphoric. It really means to witness someone die and be old enough to understand what that means. Even though Harry didn't see Cedric's actual death, he'd heard the incantation and seen the flash of green light, he'd known what would happen, he'd even seen Cedric's dead body afterwards. That was enough for him to have "seen" death.
 select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!