हैरी पॉटर
इस प्रश्न का उत्तर दो
हैरी पॉटर सवाल
Is there an official standard age for when children USUALLY start दिखा रहा है signs of magic?
Rowling: "In my books, magic almost always shows itself in a person before age 11."
-Barnes and Noble interview, March 19, 1999
^But that is not from her official site and even if those are her exact words in the interview, that is a generalization, and not saying at which age it usually shows. Yet, if it is from the books, I can't remember and HPWiki doesn't provide a source; Neville's family feared that he might be a Squib because he didn't दिखाना early signs of magic - which implies that there is not just the "before age 11" but also a specific age when magic usually shows and if it doesn't, the family becomes fearful.
SO, any official स्रोत for what age that might be?
PS.
"Most experts believe that if a child has magical abilities, they will exhibit them द्वारा the age of seven[1]."
-Harry Potter Wiki + a reference to the Deathly Hallows book's chapter 7.
^Now that evidently contradicts Rowling's own words which prove that passing the age of 7 isn't an absolute squib. But just curious: What does the chapter say to make "most experts believe" such a thing?
Could it apply to age 7 being the official standard age for when magic at the latest, usually shows in children and if it doesn't the family starts worrying?
-Barnes and Noble interview, March 19, 1999
^But that is not from her official site and even if those are her exact words in the interview, that is a generalization, and not saying at which age it usually shows. Yet, if it is from the books, I can't remember and HPWiki doesn't provide a source; Neville's family feared that he might be a Squib because he didn't दिखाना early signs of magic - which implies that there is not just the "before age 11" but also a specific age when magic usually shows and if it doesn't, the family becomes fearful.
SO, any official स्रोत for what age that might be?
PS.
"Most experts believe that if a child has magical abilities, they will exhibit them द्वारा the age of seven[1]."
-Harry Potter Wiki + a reference to the Deathly Hallows book's chapter 7.
^Now that evidently contradicts Rowling's own words which prove that passing the age of 7 isn't an absolute squib. But just curious: What does the chapter say to make "most experts believe" such a thing?
Could it apply to age 7 being the official standard age for when magic at the latest, usually shows in children and if it doesn't the family starts worrying?
|
next question » | ||
|