Richard is in the living room with Gumball. He shows Gumball a very old watch. He explains that this watch has been fought over between the Wattersons and the Finklehimer. Richard's dad retrieved the watch after a good old yodeling contest and gave it to Richard. Now, Richard gives the watch to Gumball who is still stunned द्वारा Richard's long explanation.

Gumball is on the bus with Darwin. He shows Darwin the watch and says that it's useless as it cannot tell time. In actual fact, the watch using roman numerals to tell time which Gumball doesn't know how to read. Darwin explains that Richard had offered the watch to him before offering it to Gumball. Darwin declined Richard offer, saying its "busted up cowboy junk". Gumball asked Darwin to hold the watch as he needs to tie his shoelaces. Darwin realized he's been tricked as Gumball doesn't wears shoes. Gumball appears behind Darwin's सीट saying "He who holds it, owns it". Darwin has no choice but to keep the watch.

Gumball was walking at the school hallway when Darwin rushes up to him. Darwin offers a deal to Gumball that he will keep the watch, if Richard gives them a better gift, Darwin will get to keep that gift. Gumball agrees and both of them shake hands. Darwin asks Gumball to check his hands as Darwin tries to trick him when they were shaking hands. However, Gumball hands are empty and tells Darwin to check his hands instead. Darwin's trick backfired as he still got the watch in his hand. Darwin is frustrated that he still got the watch but becomes और frustrated as Gumball disappears. Gumball reappears at the left side of the hallway, making "magic fingers" before leaving the scene.

Later on, Gumball and Darwin are in their bedroom. Darwin says that he has दिया the watch to a old man which makes Gumball worried. Gumball tells Darwin that he shouldn't have gave the watch to some बिना सोचे समझे guy but Darwin did it because he thought Gumball was trying to get rid of it. Gumball is worried to tell Richard about losing the watch. Darwin starts to cry as he thought Richard was gonna cry if he knows they लॉस्ट the watch. Gumball hugs Darwin and they start blaming each other and arguing who should tell Richard about the watch. Suddenly, Richard barges in and hugs them and ask them what are they talking about. Gumball lies and tells Richard that he was talking to Darwin about how much they liked the watch. Richard tell them that he loves them.

Gumball and Darwin goes to Bert's front yard and begs for the watch. However, Bert explains that this watch belongs to the Finklehimer. Gumball whispers to Darwin that why must he give the watch to a Finklehimer. Bert explains that its poletic justice. Gumball says to Bert that how can he turn down a crying child then tries to cry but in the end, his eyes pops out. Bert tells them to get out his lawn.

At the school lunchroom, Gumball and Darwin are having lunch. Darwin feels guilty of losing the watch but Gumball explains that they should forget about the watch and ignore about their emotions. Gumball eats a मटर but his stomach rejects it and make him spit the मटर at Darwin. Darwin asks what was that and Gumball explains that his body doesn't want him to eat due to the guilt and they must get the watch back somehow.

Back at Bert's front yard again, Bert tells them that he doesn't want to trade anything for the watch. Gumball walks to the foreground and asks what if he could give Bert, eternal youth while Darwin echos "youth". Bert is interested at the offer but Gumball उत्तरों that he doesn't have it. Darwin suggested to get Bert a girlfriend. Bert agrees but Gumball says that he need to make Bert look और younger to get him a girlfriend.

At dumps cave, षट्भुज, षट्कोण Lady asks Bert that how long he been so surprised. Bert cannot reply as his face is stretched with 4 paper clips to make him smile and look younger. After that, 2 of the paper clip drops and Bert gives a smile. षट्भुज, षट्कोण Lady asks for the check.

At Bert's front yard, Darwin tells Bert its not their fault that Bert was not compatible. Bert blames them for the back alley face lip that they used on him. Darwin explains that either it was the face lip या a bag over his head. Gumball says that he is sorry but Bert looks too old for a girlfriend. Bert tells them to go away but Gumball snatchs his cane. He explain that he's gonna beat himself and accuse Bert of doing it. Bert says Gumball must be "lillyliver" to do that. Gumball doesn't know what that means and knock himself with the cane. This makes him delusional and he starts talking gibbish. Gumball says that he forget why he is angry at Bert. The Lumpy Old Woman asks if Gumball was talking to her. Gumball उत्तरों that he still talking to Bert and Darwin offers to walk Gumball home. Gumball explains that he capable of walking घर and then goes right and out of scene. Darwin signs as he doesn't have the दिल to tell gumball that he's going the wrong way.

Later, they discover Richard did not care about the watch and was trying to get rid of it. Bert says they could have the watch back anytime. However, when the Wattersons and the Finklehimer discovers the watch costs 700 dollars, they start chasing each other on electric scooters.

At the end, the electric scooters explode, then the scene freezes and thus ending the episode.