A hero या a villian

loganm shadow is defenitly a hero

halla100 he's both but evil shadow looks more hi type

shadowwave I think evil. shoot sonic with that gun!

Seanthehedgehog shadow should be a hero because that's how eggman made him

sonnylove hero! hero! hero! hero! hero!{chanting like a dumby}

Hakufan21 He's sorta both if you ask me cause the only reason he's evil is cause he's trying to get revenge for Maria and he's good when he's rembers Maria's last wish... soooooooo its realy up to his memories with Maria.

vernorica OK SHODOW IS A GOOD GUY.........

Sonadowgirl1324 Either way, hes hot! I go with both.

Flamefox he's definetley a hero

shadowrox you could be who ever u want to be shadow, but the best chocie is o be MY hero ;)

Shadowlover2011 Brianna the Fox(Me): ACK!!! Sooo hard! Im a Villian! I have bullet guns, i hurt people i dont like, BUT I SAVE PEOPLES LIFES TOO!!!! They're both hot ANYWAYS..... Screw it. -_- I'm just gonna go with both....

Shadowlover2011 Shadow will always b my bad boy BUT my hero too! its too freakin hard.... -_-

ladydemi1 A HERO HE PROMISED TO HELP OTHER PEOPLE BECAUSE THAT WAS MARIA'S LAST WISH R.I.P MARIA MAKE GOD BLESS YOU

karlpaolo i like choas blast its so cool but Shadow and Sonic debeat Hpyer Nazo do you like to see the video this www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/396530 part 3 www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/331288 part 1 www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/333858 part 2 =) ps dont cory the part 1/2/3

Shadamy4ev HERO HERO HERO

Shadamy4ev Me:He is a- Shadow:I'm on the roll from too many girls*runs* Aqua The hedgehog:HE'S SSSSSSSOOOOOOO HOT! Me:Move it you he is a hero

shadowknuxgirl He's both!!!!!!!!!!!!!

geousumaki hero with actitude

SonicKing I would say hero because maria would want him to be one but I also say villein because He gets to use chaos blast when his red gage fills in shadow the hedgehog the video game

Daisy_Shadowgf ya so what about chaos blast? ill bet in real life he culd still use it if wanted 2! hes so my hero! *runs after him*

SonicKing he only uses chaos blast when he is really pist off

gloomy_bear he is a hero

SonicKing both to be exact

LPearlC VILLAN! VILLAN! VILLAN FOR CRYING OUT LOUD!!!! <3 THIS PIC!

jhangir i don,t know about others but he is byhero and he has a evil cuz and his evil cuz is mephil the dark