Classic Nic :p

ONE TREE HILL
pros: BROOKE DAVIS. Several other relatable and inspiring characters, perfectly formed relationships, iconic 00's moments, great high school seasons, guided me through high school a lot..
cons: Sometimes I feel I placed it so high in the first place because it's so popular. Sometimes, the storylines are crazy and annoying, cannot rewatch (especially s5 on), find it kinda overrated compared to other faves of mine. I also highly hate it's main character, so I'm not sure if I can properly love the show as much as I could nowadays :s

PRETTY LITTLE LIARS
pros: In my book it's always iconic and quotable. Perfectly planned and interesting 3 seasons, love everything main (characters, couples, friendships). Will always love the cast the most <3
cons: Used to be much more obsessed than now, after s3 it just got more and more stupid. Final reveals disappointed me a lot, don't know if I love it as much as I used to.

THE BOLD TYPE
pros: It just screamed 'Nic' from the first trailer, relatable, inspiring and great characters & friendships, killer season 1, perfect mix of friendship, self-love and fashion, my new satc!
cons: It's only one season so far, maybe the rest won't be as good. Can't find another con but also, not that sentimentally attached to it in comparison with the rest.

NEW GIRL
pros: Funniest show on earth, can rewatch multiple times, JESS & NICK, relatable adorable characters, LOVE THE GROUP, non-dramatic cute moments, now that it's over I feel more obsessed with it's essence than ever. I feel very protective of it.
cons: Sometimes, it's so silly that I couldn't take the show for serious, it just ended so I'll probably start gradually forgetting my "love" as I did with oth & pll, it's not that inspiring as OTH or TBT.

HELP ME DECIIIIIIIIDE, my Monica self is going craaaazy lol

I get what you're saying about PLL because you and I are similar in that sense. It's a show that is always going to hold a special place in your heart, has sentimental value, and characters/relationships you adore but ultimately it's a show you can't stay passionate about for a long period of time (which is why I moved it down on my list). I feel like you go back and forth on OTH al the time lol. Like you go through phases where you absolutely love the show and obsesses over it and then you go through phases where you're like eh fuck it I only care about B.Davis and Breyton lmao. And I think it's too soon to put TBT above all these other shows imo just because like you said who knows how the other seasons are gonna be. There's so many shows that have an amazing first season then just get shitty (hopefully not the bold type tho). Which is why I choose NG! It's a show where you love all the characters, relationships, can watch over and over again, and you're super passionate/protective over it! Plus, I might be a little biased because we always talk about it lol.

Well that's your daily Rana analysis! #ranaout

I'd say you overall favorite is PLL but your fave atm might be The Bold Type? And idk where to rank New Girl but based on what you said, you'd probably put New Girl as #1?

As for OTH, I'd say that even though you're the king of Brooke's fan club, the fact that you cannot/are not willing to rewatch it is a good telling about what you feel about the show. Idk I always thought that you primarily loved it bc of Brooke :)

I'm sure if TBT continues & keep having good storylines it will become your favorite but for the time being I'm picking NG because sitcoms are yous kind of shows & the ones that you enjoy watching.

OTH & PLL are more highschool Nic, plus I know you get bored with all the adults & stuff so yeap.

I think so!!

I think this EVENTUALLY will become your favorite.
For now I'd say either NG or PLL

Overall? I associate you most [of these] with PLL/think you love it most - BUT!! New Girl is an extremely close 2nd, and I easily see TBT overtaking all ♥