हैरी पॉटर बनाम ट्वाइलाइट
What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)
हैरी पॉटर बनाम ट्वाइलाइट Better of the two ? (and your reason, please)
85 fans picked: |
हैरी पॉटर
|
|||
एड्वर्ड कलेन
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
I don't find Edward to be creepy at all.
I don't think he's abusive.
He's persistant.
I admire his personal values.
I like the way he words everything he says.
I admire his self control and compassion
And so on.
I don't think anything of Harry.
Eddy's words are corny, people might think it's sweet, but honestly who says that stuff? I know he's like in the 1800's or whatever but I'm pretty sure people from the 1800's don't talk like that. "And so the lion fell in love with the lamb." And other quotes that nobody can relate to. Harry's dialouge is much more easier to relate to.
thank you cassie-1-2-3 for explaining your reason :)
Only SOME of the reasons I find Harry the best.
Well number one, eyesight isn't something that can be fixed in the wizarding world, and number two, he isn't as magic as everyone thinks he is. No one really knew what happened the night his parents died, until we find that it was his mother's love that protected him from death, not any special magic powers. The fact that he was brave enough to give up his life for others is much more impressive than giving up your girlfriend to "protect" her.
Edward: He's attractive to Bella, multi-talented and a sparkly super pale vampire that watches a girl he JUST met in her sleep. He's possessive and scary, yet described as "perfect" or "a god" on every other page. His eyes, his skin, his mouth, his face, his body, his hair, his BREATH is described as perfect, and a character should not be perfect if you want it to be effective. A character should have flaws, and not be so handsome that everyone hates Bella. He stops Bella from seeing her friend because he's possessive and jealous.
To sum it up: Harry - flawed, brave, loyal.
Edward: "Perfect" but a stalker and possessive.
He doesn't kill innocent people.
Unlike Edward.
with all his bad childhood he still grew up to become a boy with great attitude toward live. he is brave, tough not without flaw. yet i can relate to him because all of his mistake is something human especially for teenager (hormon and all that). he always loyal to his friend even when there is a little 'fight' between them. mainly with ron.
sometimes maybe he came off as self-righteous and blame everything but himself but the more the story unfold he learn from his past mistakes to become a better man.
unlike what everybody think he is not the 'perfect hero' and he had his fair share of mistakes and bad judgement. he never want to be anything but just another boy, maybe with his parents still alive. he is not judging people by their wealth but by how they treat other people.
in the deathly hollow he willingly sacrifice himself even without knowledge that he will be able to return. and when he could choose to stay in the afterlife with his parents, he choose to go back to help his friends.
Edward:
handsome? not really..
attitude? dude i'm a girl and i'm not even THAT dramatic toward live
"skin of a killer" *laugh* sure, sure.
"what if i'm the bad guy" I've seen my fair share of bad boys and no, you're not even close.
cheesy pick up line? try saying "and the lion fell in love with the lamb" to my face and i sure hell will called the mental hospital.
try to stop me meeting my friends? Hoo.. let's just BREAKUP than. you have no respect for me i won't give any to you.
साइन इन करें या शामिल होइए फैन्पॉप पेअपनी टिप्पणी जोड़ने के लिए