it is the esme spot lol =)

It's unfair to pick since they're both so very different.

yes but they also ahve some of the same things in commen! so u must think very hard!

esme is more of a mother to me, renee is a good friend, but i don't think i'd like having her as my mom. she's sweet but a VERY big bubble head

yea sure esme!

haha ^^

i didnt have to think at all. esme has such motherly instinmcs and shes so nice. plus i would love alice as a sis. haha

She's so mummy-ish

nothing against rene but shes more like a child than a mother even if shes cool and derstandig. esme wawritten to sound like a perfect mother and she is in my point of view as she's nurturing and caring

For me .. it's based on; motherly instinct. Which in my opinion, Esme has more than Renee! Renee is like .. a wacky blonde nutty friend, whereas Esme has that .. motherly thing about her. Which sadly, my mother doesn't even have. The only thing with me is, I'm a contact person *nods*

Esme of course! (:

Renee is ditzy. She's more like older version of Bella, only worse.
Esme is agile and more motherly.
Emse for sure!

Definately Esme!! She is so motherly, and I would love to have Alice as a sister!! Who wouldnt?? I LOVE JACOB BLACK!!

She has be perfect:D. And Charlie or Emmett some my dad:D

Renee is more of the fun aunt to me. Esme is just so loving, motherly, and caring! Plus she is like the best mother ever!

Esme's amazing !!!! she will be an awesome mum

Renee is too overprotective Esme is just very nice

esme all the way

Esme is like fun and will never get old and Renee will.

if esme was my mom that would mean i was a vampire or a vampires wife so that is why i say her lol

well esme is loving caring while renne is outgoing fun risk taking kind so ........ idk

esme

my mother, of course!!!
S2

Esme is my mother and my father is Carlisle.
I am a vampire.
Esme and Carlisle forever!!! S2
Their love is the purest and there has never existed and will exist equal love!
I love love them! S2

i love Esme i just do

i LUV esm seh is pretty!
-98

Esme all the way. Much more motherly- and who wouldn't want to have a vampire as great as Esme for their mom!

i would rather have esme as my mother because i think she is really nice and she really cares about her family and she is so nice.... i never have heard her say 1 bad thing about her family!!!!

she's so caring and understanding... and like they say in breaking dawn... she has a loving nature

haha ^^^^^^
i'm carolinzinha!

Esme is fun
not just that but she'll never grow old,
caring,
understaning,
loving nature,
and more!

Esme 4 sure she's caring loving understanding n she'll stay with u 4ever she will b there 4 u wen u need her n lets face it esme is FREAKIN awsome like she'll protect u no matter wat she'll fight 4 u

Esme is a wonderfull mother