इस प्रश्न का उत्तर दो

वाद-विवाद सवाल

Are Americans ignorant about other countries?

So, I was just पढ़ना on some other internet site and an user there कहा that American aren't concerned with other countries, that they know little about other countries and most certainly don't know anything about politics in other countries, unless they
- see the country as a thread.
- can make money there.

He was not talking about the government या anything, just about the average American.

Any opinions? What do आप think about the knowledge of Americans concerning other countries?

*
this would be a pick ;) not a सवाल for "answers"
Snerkie posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
I did not really want a yes/no discussion, but rather people's personal outlook on it... therefor I asked it here. I think it would be better as a मंच post, but no one seems to read them.
Sappp posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
 Sappp posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
next question »

वाद-विवाद जवाब

germany123 said:
its always sort of annoying to follow these conversations on answers- such a pity the मंचों are empty (i get why आप पोस्टेड it here..i would just प्यार to have the टिप्पणियाँ in order)

its something i wonder aboot, too. it seems that these days its a pretty much guaranteed icebreaker in germany..much like talking aboot the weather..if youre in a convo where आप might otherwise not be comfortable discussing things:

mention how झाड़ी, बुश sucks (can we get over that already?) and how shallow and ignorant americans are and आप will pretty much have everyone at the तालिका, टेबल agreeing with you(except me who then sighs and tries to change the subject या give feeble attempts at objectivity like "hmmm i wonder if 300 million inhabitants can ge generalized like that"). everyone always knows a story of some american who asked if europeans had subways/toasters/electricity etc and yes, i have encountered one who was surprised to learn that berlin was a city in germany saying: i thought that was a wall! but that was some 15 साल old kid who hadnt paid attention in class that day.
its the danger of the single story i guess..repeat one stereotype and आप will suddenly start having a subjective view on how thats true withoot exception.
(link)<-- great talk on the "single story".



i myself am the first to admit that i know NOTHING and द्वारा that i mean absolutely NOTHING aboot asia. who rules japan? no idea. captial of laos?no idea..and no one can argue that asia is some kind of irrelevant continent where nothing happens. its pretty embarrassing but surely not true for all germans.

i am not quite sure how the myth came aboot..there must be something that started it?
i wonder if there is any statistic that would prove the stereotype!?



select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Test scores mean nothing.
renrae posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
आप didn't need to मिटाइए your comments, आप know.
renrae posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
Oh, the Hell with it...here goes!
susanslover posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
MissKnowItAll said:
I don't know.

It kind of feels like Britain is the stalkerish ex-lover of America. We know all of America's friends, hobbies and beliefs, but America knows nothing about us. And one दिन she's gonna turn round and say 'who the hell are you?!'
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
*Facebook-style LIKED*
Cinders posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
लोल XD
LoopyLuna96 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
lol. I do agree. :D
MissKnowItAll posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
bri-marie said:
I, as an American, think we are ignorant of a lot of things. Thanks to our media and our schools, we have these distorted, backwards, "stereo-typical" ideas about other countries. My Geography professor was astounded because, in my class of fifty people, I was the only one who knew Mexico was part of the North American continent.

We know very little about other countries politics या how those countries feel about their own politics. Many people I know just assume that anything that isn't a democracy is bad and that that country is severely unhappy and wants to change it. None of them are even interested in studying या looking into the true facts. They gobble up anything that's handed to them, regardless of the true facts.

*NOTE: This is from my experience with people; my family, my high school, my college, my job, volunteer work, extracurricular activities, my फ्रेंड्स and their immediate families. I'm sure there are American's who are और informed, but I have yet to encounter any in a face-to-face way.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
robothor1111 said:
I believe that we are ignorant of a good many things, but I try not to be. I study other material because I don't want to fit that stereotype.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
Cinders said:
I think this is a common stereotype that Americans suffer. Like all stereotypes, it is rooted in a small grain of truth. The United States of America is a vast country, and we have many interesting cultures and regions within it. The stereotype is that Americans don't travel internationally, but they do travel a LOT within in the United States. I know few people who have never been out of their घर town.

That's not an excuse for not knowing about the world. Canada is just as big as the US, and does not suffer from that stereotype. And even if an American HAS never left her घर town her whole life, that's also no excuse for not knowing about anything outside of it.

Being a masters student at a public university, I associate with other college students, a large percentage of whom have traveled outside of the country. And even if they haven't, they know enough about it to discuss it. This is not to say that there aren't ill-informed या ignorant Americans. It's just saying that our population shouldn't be generalized - just like any other population shouldn't be generalized.

EDIT: Also, just to keep things in perspective. When I lived in Belgium, I mingled with Americans and Europeans alike, as well as others. They asked from where I had moved to Brussels, and I said, "Tashkent." Americans and Europeans alike could not tell me if that was a city, country या region of the world. Without the use of Google, how many of आप can tell me?

I feel like this stereotype is huge in Europe, and a little bit in the Middle East from my experiences in Egypt. And that feels kind of easy for Europeans, because they are a very international continent (subcontinent?), and most of them have been across युरोप from Lisbon to Kiev, and Sicily to Oslo, and there are a lot of countries there. Europeans even पार करना, क्रॉस the Mediterranian to vacation in Alexandria या Tunis या Beirut. Europeans may even hop the pond and explore the United States and know a lot about that.

But (and this is a genuine question) what do आप know about countries that aren't nearby, या good travel destinations? What do आप know about Angola या Bhutan या Tajikistan? Out of curiosity.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Well, this is kind of like how I felt. I life in a small country so most my vacation are outside of it. But there is a lot of USA so it might take some while for people to get tired of taking there vacations there. I jus wantes some opinions from Americans.
Sappp posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
I also asked this because it such a stereotype in युरोप and I want to know a little bit और about how Americans really look at the world. For example: how much is there on आप news on the current Roma issue in France? In युरोप that is quite a thing, just wondering how the news रिपोर्ट on things like that is in the USA..,
Sappp posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
[Answer has just been edited]
Cinders posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
drunksheep said:
I'm not american, but i say yes.
FIRST: AMERICA is the whole continent, and not just USA. They're ignoring Latin America.
And then, Sylvester Stallone came to my country (Brazil) to shoot a movie and he कहा these words about my country:
"I like Brazil. आप can blow all the country, and the people will say 'Thank you! Here's a monkey for you!'." They think they're alone in this country, they're the best of the world and all the rest is shit. That makes me really anger!

PS: Once a girl asked me where Brazil is, and i कहा "It's a country...", and she "I thought it was some poor region of Africa!" -_-
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
1) Sylvester Stalone द्वारा no means represents me, या the American people anymore than Mel Gibson, with his anti-Semitic coments, represents Christians. 2) Some Americans are dumb as posts. Some just aren't informed. But that doesn't mean the whole country is filled with egotistical cretins.
Cinders posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
I did not ask about America, I asked about Americans. As far as I know people from the USA do call themselves Americans.
Sappp posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
Good point, Sappp.
Cinders posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
Monrose said:
I'm not an American, but I get a very bad impression of them in general, mostly when I discuss with them. I actually heard yesterday that a lot of Americans think Norway is the capital city of Sweden... And some doesn't even know that Norway is a country at all. Come on, we're one of the world's richest countries!
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Those Americans have obviously never heard of the Oslo Accords. ;o)
Cinders posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
Heard of what?
Monrose posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
Where are all these stupid Americans I keep hearing about, I live in Minnesota and have yet to come face-to-face with them. P.S. Norway's one of my चोटी, शीर्ष five European countries
Diasasis posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
XDRoseLuvsHP said:
I believe we are. I know that when I talk to people from other countries, and I mean people who are my age, they all know everything about American politics, even और than most of my फ्रेंड्स know. And we know virtually nothing about other countries. If आप were to ask me the president of Canada, I'd say, "Um... I have no idea". That's pretty sad. We only know what we learn from news stations like लोमड़ी, फॉक्स News and MSNBC. Neither of those are reliable because they are so biased. CNN is better, but still fairly biased. Then there's Channel 2 News! The problem with that station is that they have no और of an idea as to what's going on in the world than the average American teenager. Most of their news is unimportant and just fluff stories, as far as I've seen. So unless anyone reads the paper (like, The New York Times and stuff) then people aren't going to know much, and will remain ignorant (and I don't read the newspaper except for the comics, so I'm no better XD).
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
I do not think it's just Americans,I do not know who the president of Canada is,either.
alismouha posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
haha, I don't know about the president but I could tell आप who the prime minister is...
Diasasis posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
sapherequeen said:
I am American, but I'll have to admit...there are evidently things of other countries that we are ignorant of. I can think of plenty of examples off the चोटी, शीर्ष of my head.

Today, during my history class, a girl asked our teacher why some Indian Americans (not Native Americans) refer to themselves as 'Asian'. Our teacher explained that since the country India is part of Asia, they are technically Asian people. Like Canadians, Mexicans, and citizens of the United States are all generally Americans (North Americans if आप want to be और specific).

So, my classmate then states, "But why do Indians speak a different language then?"

-_-

So according to some people, आप are not part of the same continent if आप don't speak the same language....which is ironic because in her own country, there are those who speak Spanish, German, French etc. Heck, we even have a teacher at my school who speaks Hindi. Yet she would call them Americans??

That's just one of my examples of this.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
Twilight_Dream said:
in ways its true. i don't feel the need to know that much about other countries unless i take a liking to a certain one, if i might हटाइए there one day, या if that country has certain important political matters i should know about. so instead of those cases, why WOULD i need to know?
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
Lawli-gagger said:
I wasn't sure that Americans were required to KNOW about other countries...thought we had our own problems over here.

Just saying...
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
harold said:
Yes, Americans are ignorant about other countries. Not all Americans, but certainly in every American country there are people who are ignorant of even the other American countries, let alone countries on other continents. Americans, no matter their nationality, are also ignorant to greater या lesser extent, about their own countries. For instance, I am an United States American, and I have no idea who the Secretary of State was under the 11th US President, James Polk. There might even have been और than one during his presidency! I have no idea! Sure, I could look this up, but it wouldn't change the fact that I am currently a complete ignoramus regarding that cabinet.

To address your और detailed points, I don't think most Americans are concerned with other countries as a threat या as money-making opportunities. Maybe some North Americans (residents of Canada, US and Mexico) are, but I'd venture to guess that most Bolivians, to name one type of American, aren't terribly concerned with the belligerence या financial liquidity of New Zealand. Some would say that they should be, what with globalization of economies, but such a large number of Americans are living below the poverty level that such concerns aren't really "on their radar".
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
hetalianstella said:
As an American, I certainly don't think every single one of us are like that. But there certainly are a lot.

Considering in our education system we don't really learn या have courses in anything but America until at least High School, we naturally inhabit the idea that there's not much out there besides us. Which of course is not true.

Now I am American, and I प्यार learning about other nations. The culture and history of all these other places fascinate me. But I am only one person.

While back in 8th grade, at least 1/2 of my class could not even identify the continent of युरोप on a map.........not even kidding.
But I'm not totally surprised considering in my school (I'm in High School now), I have yet to see a single world map hanging on the wall. I usually only see maps of the US.
But then again that may just be my school.

But over time I do see us slowly paying और attention to the rest of the world. However, I still do think we have a long way to go.
But I believe that the biggest problem would have to be in our education system.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
next question »