इस प्रश्न का उत्तर दो

बिना सोचे समझे सवाल

Walt Disney, या Studio Ghibli?

(Nausicaa from Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind and Pocahontas, from Pocahontas :D)
 Walt Disney, या Studio Ghibli?
 blackpanther666 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
next question »

बिना सोचे समझे जवाब

panisepic said:
Studio Ghibli
Their फिल्में have और variety and they're not afraid to not have a happy ending. They deal with और real life problems in और realistic manners (environment, war, family, love,relationships,feelings) and while most of their फिल्में have some sort of magic या alternate setting, their characters are still incredibly realistic and are easy to connect to. I find it easier to relate to many a Ghibli character than a डिज़्नी one. While I did see some Ghibli फिल्में when I was really young, I did pretty much watch Disney, heck I still do.
Another thing Ghibli does very well is they make the फिल्में accessible to people of all ages. While they do deal with things in less childish manners (they don't solve problems through song) out of all of their फिल्में (I looked up every film from Nausicaa to Princess Kaguya) only 3 are rated PG-13 (The Wind Rises, Tales From Earthsea, and Princess Mononoke) every other movie is either G या PG (exception; Grave of the Fireflies is Unrated). My friend and I went to see The Wind Rises in theaters and her dad went with us, he was rather reluctant to go as it was an animated movie (presumably meaning it's for kids) long story short I got my फ्रेंड्स dad addicted to Ghibli.
Another thing I absolutely, I mean ABSOLUTELY प्यार about Ghibli THE FEMALE CHARACTERS ARE AMAZING. Their lives don't revolve around waiting for a man to दिखाना up, and they don't sing their time away. (Yes I know not every डिज़्नी movie has singing, but it's something considered very iconic to डिज़्नी and is common in most if not all of their most लोकप्रिय movies)While yes डिज़्नी is creating better female characters, Ghibli has been doing it since the early 1980's, it's something they've become known for, it's something they दिखाना no sign of stopping. Not to mention they do this while still putting in great male leads don't get me wrong.
While Studio Ghibli is slowing its production down, they're going back to pre-Porco Rosso freelancing and it will most likely be a long time before we see any और Ghilbi फिल्में in theaters, meanwhile डिज़्नी is making just as much money as ever it could, Ghibli is something that will remain in peoples hearts. Ghibli is something that will stick with a person from childhood and through adulthood, like I said, being और accessible to all ages and dealing with issues in a non-sing song way.

That is to say I don't like all Ghibli movies, and I don't hate all डिज़्नी फिल्में I'm hoping to see Big Hero 6 this weekend, but I'm also planning on seeing The Tale of Princess Kaguya is December when it comes to my city. While I do prefer Ghibli I do like Disney, it has it's charms. I would be rather hesitant to really say one is completely better than the other. I think it is important to acknowledge just the fact that डिज़्नी is way way way और लोकप्रिय than Ghibli in the U.S at least. (Frozen actually just broke Disney's Japanese DVD sales द्वारा just recently selling 3million copies since it's July 16th release).

select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
tl;dr Ghibli is cool. Sorry for that really long, I don't even know what that is.
panisepic posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
haynay24 said:
Nothing can be compare with Disney
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
Zeppie said:
Extremely tough सवाल :(

The animations from Studio Ghibli are absolutely stunning and beautiful, a kind of beauty that डिज़्नी hasn't quite touched on before. But to be fair, I have only seen the work of Studio Ghibli in हाल का years/late teens, which leads me to my अगला point...

The work of डिज़्नी is just so nostalgic for me, I grew up with it, and I प्यार that traditional डिज़्नी magic, songs, characters, everything.

So I pick Disney.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
KataraLover said:
डिज़्नी द्वारा FAR
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
CF_the_Kid2 said:
I'm gonna go with Disney.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
NagisaTomoya said:
While डिज़्नी does have some good movies, they always involve the same things (Love, Singing, Princesses, ETC...) whereas Studio Ghibli shakes things up and is different with each story. I feel like डिज़्नी gets so old after a while so I must pick Studio Ghibli. Have आप seen Grave of the fireflies? डिज़्नी could never make a movie like that without making it kid friendly, and WWII is not a friendly topic at all... See, Studio Ghibli may be an एनीमेशन company, but they are not afraid to stray away from the stereotypical डिज़्नी एनीमेशन and will make masterpieces.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
kittyluv57 said:
Gomen to all the डिज़्नी fans, but I'm really going to have to go with Studio Ghibli on this one. Honestly, even as a child डिज़्नी फिल्में tended to get old to me. Sure, they were great in their own way. But they always created the same romance, same गाना theme, same kid-friendly atmosphere, etc. But Studio Ghibli has really hit me in ways that डिज़्नी never did. The stories are all unique, they vary each time. The characters were also varied, and far और likeable to me than some princesses. Not to mention special प्रॉप्स to them for their animation, which blows me away every time. It could just be that डिज़्नी isn't as nostalgic to me as it is to so many others despite growing up with it, but in terms of प्यार and enjoyment factor, Studio Ghibli takes the cake.
select as best answer
 Gomen to all the डिज़्नी fans, but I'm really going to have to go with Studio Ghibli on this one. Honestly, even as a child डिज़्नी फिल्में tended to get old to me. Sure, they were great in their own way. But they always created the same romance, same गाना theme, same kid-friendly atmosphere, etc. But Studio Ghibli has really hit me in ways that डिज़्नी never did. The stories are all unique, they vary each time. The characters were also varied, and far और likeable to me than some princesses. Not to mention special प्रॉप्स to them for their animation, which blows me away every time. It could just be that डिज़्नी isn't as nostalgic to me as it is to so many others despite growing up with it, but in terms of प्यार and enjoyment factor, Studio Ghibli takes the cake.
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Agreed
NagisaTomoya posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
tinkerbell66799 said:
Studio Ghibli definitely!
select as best answer
 Studio Ghibli definitely!
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
Siren-Lamia said:
Walt Disney
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
simpleplan said:
Studio Ghibli
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
next question »