गेम ऑफ थ्रोन्स
add a link
Rape in Westeros: What “Game of Thrones” could learn from “Mad Max: Fury Road”
Rape in Westeros: What “Game of Thrones” could learn from “Mad Max: Fury Road”
The problem isn't that rape exists in "Game of Thrones" — it's that the दिखाना refuses to justify why
कीवर्ड्स: गेम ऑफ थ्रोन्स, mad max: fury road, sansa stark 5x06
|
I remember visiting this website once...
It was called Rape in Westeros: What “Game of Thrones” could learn from “Mad Max: Fury Road” - Salon.com
Here's some stuff I remembered seeing:
Rape in Westeros: What “Game of Thrones” could learn from “Mad Max: Fury Road”
The problem isn\'t that rape exists in "Game of Thrones" — it\'s that the show refuses to justify
Topics: TV, Game of Thrones, sophie turner, ivan rheon, alfie allen, d.b. weiss, David Benioff, Rape, Entertainment News
Charlize Theron in "Mad Max: Fury Road," Sophie Turner in "Game of Thrones"
Just over a year ago I wrote a piece on HBO’s “Game Of Thrones” questioning why the show’s creators had written a rape scene into the show’s season-four episode “Breaker Of Chains.” That episode was notable for re-telling a scene from the book with a lot more brutality, meaning critics like myself could compare the source material and the scene in question, side-by-side. It led me to return to the pilot of “Game Of Thrones,” to examine another scene that played out very differently in the book than it did in the show. Neither sex scene, in the books, is wholly consensual, but on-screen, they are significantly less so. In the pilot, Daenerys (Emilia Clarke) is forcibly penetrated by Khal Drogo (Jason Momoa) on their wedding night; in “Breaker Of Chains,” Jamie (Nikolaj Walder-Costeau) pushes his sister/lover to the ground and rapes her. In the show, both Dany and Cersei (Lena Headey) sob through their ordeals.
Now these two sobbing women are joined by a third. Last night, Sansa Stark (Sophie Turner) was similarly assaulted by her new husband, Ramsay Bolton (Iwan Rheon), while her former foster brother Theon (Alfie Allen) was forced to watch. Unlike the first two scenes, Sansa’s storyline can’t really be compared to what happens in the books: She’s been combined with another minor character from “A Dance With Dragons” named Jeyne Poole. Jeyne is pushed to impersonate Arya Stark and marry Ramsay by none other than Tywin Lannister, who is now dead. Ramsay forces Theon to perform sex acts on Jeyne, regularly abuses her, and threatens to have her fornicate with a dog, including, presumably, many more mundane acts of sexual assault on a regular basis. Crucially, perhaps, for this topic, “A Dance With Dragons” stops short of narrating Ramsay’s rape of Jeyne.
“Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken” offers no such restraint. The essential nature of the story remains the same—Ramsay is a sadist, Theon is trapped in Ramsay’s thrall, and both Jeyne and Sansa are at Ramsay’s mercy. But the depiction is very different. Rather than depicting both Theon and Jeyne being victimized, together, “Game Of Thrones” depicts Ramsay raping Sansa, while Theon watches. The camera stays on his face. All we hear of her is sobbing, as his face contorts in horror.
As I wrote in April, this is not a turn of events that is totally unexpected.
On the eve of her engagement to Ramsay Bolton—even if, as her serving woman tells her, “the North remembers,” even if the man that was once Theon is waiting in the wings, even if Littlefinger is watching her back—Sansa is now facing a life where she will be raped, daily. It’s a choice, of sorts, made between one bleak prospect and another. We, the audience, do not know exactly what she is thinking. But I would not be surprised to hear her echo Elizabeth Smart, as she rejects the notion of Stockholm syndrome. “Everything I did I did to survive.”
But. I wrote that as a way of articulating what I believe to be true about Sansa (and Jeyne Poole, for that matter): These women are not merely victims: They are survivors in a world that is built to be inhospitable to them. The idea that they are victims makes them passive in their own lives, and what we see from both Sansa and Jeyne are their struggles to make themselves heard, even while under the worst kind of torture.
The problem with the graphic brutality of last night’s scene is not, necessarily, that it is rape. One only needs to glance at the news to find stories of unconscionable sexual abuse directed towards young women; in the world of TV, Jane Campion’s “Top Of The Lake” is a haunting, beautiful miniseries about a spate of rapes in a small town that focuses with unrelenting empathy on the shape and aftermath of trauma. At its best, Westeros is a way to comment on the cheaply held respect for women’s bodies in our own world.
But the scene in “Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken,” undercuts Sansa’s agency in what is happening to her. She is a player in this game of thrones, as evidenced by her icy grace as she walks to the godswood, accompanied by no one except the foster-brother who betrayed her family; to her regal put-down of the besotted servant girl who tries to scare her out of marrying Ramsay. She’s had a devil’s choice, between one kind of hell and another, but she did choose. When Ramsay orders her to undress, she begins to do so. Her fear gets the best of her for a minute. But then when Ramsay rips open her dress, though she’s terrified, she doesn’t resist. She is maintaining her own composure; she is owning her own dreadful choice, insofar as anything she can do in this terrible situation is a choice. But then the scene stops depicting her. Her sobs become the score for someone else’s story. The episode loses sight, literally, of who she is; furthermore, and more damning, it seems to take from her, in this most vulnerable moment, the only thing that she truly has.
My guess is that the show’s creators were attempting to salvage some of Sansa’s dignity—or, more cynically, their own; they’ve heard a lot from viewers about gratuitous female nudity and/or torture porn. (I noticed the actors involved were already prepared, Monday morning, to make the publicity rounds defending the scene.) But they mis-stepped again; focusing on Theon in that crucial moment stripped Sansa of even more of her dignity. Perhaps I seem like an unfair critic, arguing that this scene didn’t do it right, and that scene didn’t either. But rape isn’t a simple or easy topic; it
And while the scene itself is important to discuss, one of the most damning things about “Game Of Thrones,” up until now, is how little it has acknowledged or processed the many rapes that have occurred in its world. The scene between Jaime and Cersei was never discussed again, and Dany goes on to fall in love with Khal Drogo. Partly, as I’ve discussed before, this comes from the show’s vested interest in shocking and titillating its largely first-world audience with a level of body horror and violence that is presently experienced almost entirely by the neediest populations on the planet—populations that can’t afford HBO. Partly, it also seems to be a real miscomprehension of sexual assault suffered by women in a patriarchal world. Myles McNutt put it well:
The issue with the show returning to rape as a trope is not simply because there have been thinkpieces speaking out against it, and is not solely driven by the rational concerns lying at the heart of those thinkpieces. It’s also that the show has lost my faith as a viewer that the writers know how to articulate the aftermath of this rape effectively within the limited time offered to each storyline in a given episode and given season. Three of the show’s main female characters have now been raped, and yet the show has struggled to make this a part of their character history—their rapes may function as narrative climaxes, but the rising action has never been particularly well-drawn, and the denouement has been non-existent.
Whether it is Stockholm Syndrome or “Game Of Thrones,” it appears that our culture will go out of its way—well, well out of its way—to ignore or sideline the story of women dealing with rape on their own terms. It remains to be seen how “Game Of Thrones” is going to handle this in the episodes remaining this season. Fortunately for Weiss and Benioff, though, they can look to the undeniably testosterone-fueled “Mad Max: Fury Road,” which just premiered on Friday, for some pointers on how to write about women as agents of their own fate in a man’s world.
The film—brainchild of writer/director George Miller—is about a group of women struggling to escape from a male slaver and his many (male) followers. Most are “breeders,” his sex slaves that he is using to beget children. Other women slaves are chained to milking machines, supplying breast milk for the starving soldiers. And one is a maimed driver and fighter, who is the one attempting to lead the other women to freedom, with untold horrors in her past. And yet, as novelist Saladin Ahmed observed, despite the film’s R-rating, sex slavery, visibly pregnant “breeder,” and any amount of blood and gore, “Mad Max: Fury Road” does not feature a rape scene. The film is a vision of fighting oppression, a battle epic of overcoming the odds. Rape happened in this world, yes. But there is no reason to depict it in the film.
The problem, as ever, with “Game Of Thrones”’ rape is not that it exists but that it fails to adequately justify
it exists. Miller’s film has incredible vision and purpose and energy. Every moment is considered and vital. “Game Of Thrones” doesn’t feel that way. A world of violence is not a narrative, it’s just a theater of horror. There is a real disconnect in this show between the character arcs and the brutality of each moment; between the subtle storytelling and the entirely unsubtle treatment of its women. It creates a dissonance of attempting to identify with characters before seeing them suffer almost cartoonish horror in the arena of the show; the violence is titillation.
But rape isn’t mere violence; it’s not a punch to the head or a knife through the ribs. It’s an act that attempts to divorce a person’s soul from their body; to imitate the language of intimacy in what is purely cruelty. It is a kind of murder, except afterwards, the victim can still walk and talk and breathe. I question any depiction of rape that seeks to add to a woman’s violation in the text by further robbing her of her dignity in how that story is told. And at this point, with HBO’s “Game Of Thrones,” I’m questioning
EXCLUSIVE: R.E.M.\'s Mike Mills remembers band\'s David Letterman appearances, how he broke the news of his retirement
Let\'s revisit that time David Letterman lost his cool and told a guest to "shut the f*ck up"
David Letterman\'s secret weapon: How being TV\'s biggest grump made (and maybe even saved) his career
How "The Best Show" keeps us calling in for more: "Some people think getting hung up on is an honor"
"Morrissey\'s hair, bongs made of apples, MTV\'s 120 Minutes": Inside this month\'s hottest new books
Right now: Bill Murray\'s insane walk down Broadway, covered in ... cake?
Please let David Letterman go: From "Mad Men" to "Sopranos," our obsession with endings gets everything backwards
Simon Pegg has a Franzen moment: Book criticism needs a poptimist revolution to take down genre snobs
The 6 best sex scenes from "Bachelorette" host Chris Harrison\'s romance novel: "His body and hers curled around the epicenter of pleasure"
Christina Hendricks is "Mad" about technology in her "Sesame Street" appearance
Democratic Senator Claire McCaskill gives up on "Game of Thrones" over "gratuitous" rape scene
The science of "Steggy": ’Shipping TV characters scratches these two biological itches
David Letterman\'s right-hand man Paul Shaffer gets candid: "What am I going to do with myself every day?"
Snoop Dogg\'s voting for Hillary: America needs "a perspective other than the male’s train of thought"
The most sexist and degrading "Bachelorette" to date: This season is definitely not here for the right reasons
Salon\'s Michael Stipe exclusive: "Looking back is something I\'m not that good at"
David Letterman\'s brilliant vulnerability: He has always been "naked and afraid" behind that trademark smirk
Jimmy Fallon chokes up in Letterman goodbye: "We looked to him to say something"
Eddie Vedder serenades David Letterman with one last, moody performance
David Letterman and Tom Hanks prove it\'s never too late to pick up a selfie stick
David Letterman staffer: Madonna was so high the night she dropped 14 F-bombs
Like many on this list, this finale comes up in practically every “best finales” conversation; unlike the others, it was part of an all-time-great series, as well. Though the episode-ending cut to black is widely remembered, it isn’t a gimmick; the debate over whether the cut represents the sudden death of Tony Soprano is of a piece with the paranoia and anxiety that underpinned Tony’s life in the mob.
“St. Elsewhere,” “The Last One,” 1988
Not that gimmicks are necessarily bad. The six-season medical drama “St. Elsewhere” would be little-remembered, were it not for the final episode that reveals the events of the series take place inside the mind of Tommy Westphall, an autistic child with a snow globe containing a mini-hospital. Given how many other shows’ characters appeared on “St. Elsewhere” during its run, the finale also gave rise to the idea of the “Tommy Westphall Multiverse,” a system whereby everything from “CSI” to “Gidget” is part of Tommy’s imaginings. Any episode that keeps people talking this long about an ‘80s medical show has to have done something right.
“Six Feet Under,” “Everyone’s Waiting,” 2005
After five years of watching the Fisher family assist in the burial of total strangers, we get to see them die, one after another, in a fantasy daughter Claire has as she drives away from home. But what’s most memorable about the final sequence is not the deaths but the wonderful lives the Fishers and their loved ones live, years after the show ends, with marriages, time together and a peaceful acceptance of death.
“Sex and the City,” “An American Girl in Paris,” 2004
Like “Six Feet Under,” “Sex and the City” sent us off with a glimpse into its protagonists’ futures, though we were left to assume a great deal; all four were in stable romantic relationships (and if you ignore the complications of the subsequent films, they stay that way forever). But the finale struck a strange, melancholy note, too; though she’s finally landed Big, Carrie observes that the relationship that’s been the most reliable is the one she’s had with herself.
After some unsteady seasons, “Frasier” righted itself with a finale that nailed the show’s balance of erudite humor and starry-eyed romantic impulses. Frasier finally leaves Seattle in order to pursue a relationship with his perfect match, played by Laura Linney. This is probably the only sitcom that could have gotten away with quoting Tennyson in its climactic moments.
“Newhart,” in which Bob Newhart played a Vermont innkeeper, though amiable, was less memorable than its predecessor, “The Bob Newhart Show.” And, indeed, the show was, in its final minutes, dismissed as ancillary to “The Bob Newhart Show,” when Newhart woke up to his “Bob Newhart Show” wife in their Chicago apartment and explained his strange dream -- in which he’d been a Vermont innkeeper. He goes back to sleep, where perhaps he dreams of a future hanging out with nerdy scientists on "The Big Bang Theory."
The absurdist comedy ended with a glimpse into the future, a familiar trick. But in a wink at the earnestness of shows like “Six Feet Under,” “30 Rock” continued its running joke of Kenneth the page’s seeming immortality, showing him looking exactly the same and running NBC. There were other plot machinations, but “30 Rock” was always more funny than plot-driven, and the loopy finale was no exception.
“The Larry Sanders Show,” “Flip,” 1998
On the last episode of the HBO series about the doings at a late-night talk show, the show within “The Larry Sanders Show” effectively takes over, with the fictional show’s series finale and the real show’s series finale becoming one and the same for much of the episode. Sanders ends both the real and fake shows by allowing his audience to “flip” channels -- as he’d done many times before, but never as poignantly.
Diane, the long-departed character for whom Sam had carried a torch for years, returns, and the pair decide to flee Boston and the group of barflies -- but the relationship doesn’t work out, in the end. Some things aren’t meant to be -- but your friends will still be at the bar, in perpetuity.
The most-watched single episode of television ever depicts the end of the Korean War, with all the members of the cast headed back to the States. Its iconic stature in the culture makes distinctions of “good” or “bad” almost irrelevant -- it just is, and it casts a shadow still whenever a show attempts to wrap things up.
The corrupt cop at the show’s center was neither quite let off the hook nor quite punished; he was sentenced to live his life in the ignominy of a desk job, far from the action he thrived on -- though in the show’s final seconds, he reaches for a gun. In a TV universe where characters are very often sentenced to punishment or entirely let off the hook, the complexity of Vic’s situation was entirely refreshing.
There was one big looming question in the last episode of Vince Gilligan\'s "Breaking Bad": Would all of Walter\'s past wrongdoings catch up to him? And in the end, we got our answer tidily delivered to us. Despite finding a way to hand off all of his earnings to his family and being able to save Jesse from the line of fire, meth production took everything from him (not even once!) -- including his life, ultimately. And let\'s not forget "Felina\'s" carefully curated songs that played throughout, including Bad Finger\'s "Baby Blue" during the iconic closing shot.
"Justified" managed to deliver its shock value by erring on the side of caution. Though avid viewers were positive the finale would kill off Boyd, the creator of the show Graham Yost knew from the very beginning that he would be keeping this character alive, giving the core trio the closest thing to a perfect, happy ending as possible. Much like the pilot episode of the series, the finale returned to a format free of exposition, letting its main characters drift around -- and breathe their final breaths.
How do you send off one of TV\'s most celebrated oddballs? You orchestrate an over-the-top and thoroughly delightful musical extravaganza that resembles a "live-action \'Where\'s Waldo\' where every single person is Waldo." J.J. Abrams. Neil DeGrasse Tyson. Cindy Lauper. Big Bird. Who wasn\'t there? As many noted following the finale, the last 30 minutes felt a lot like a symbolic farewell to irony -- fitting for the man who pretended to lean hard right for his entire late-night tenure. "We’ll meet again some sunny day!" it concluded.
Make Summer More Poetic with These 10 International Works
8 Illustrated Books for Every Age and Every Summer Reading List
10 Great Science Reads That You Can Take to the Beach
Turn Summer into a Literary Field Day with these 9 Collections of Non-Fiction Sports Writing
Travel to Foreign Lands in 10 Newly Translated Novels
Get Lost in 8 Great Biographies – from Lawrence of Arabia to Margaret Fuller
Explore Diverse Cultures Through Varied Genres with These 8 New Works
8 Great Essay Collections for Your Reading Pleasure
Looking for Fresh Fiction for your Summer Reading?
Jay-Z and Beyonce bailed out Baltimore and Ferguson protesters: Report Salon Staff
Amy Schumer perfectly parodies the insanity of child pageantry Colin Gorenstein
Reporting on Waco biker gang killings reveals disparities in news coverage Jenny Kutner
The one tweet that may hold the meaning to "Mad Men\'s" final scene Salon Staff
"Mad Men" finale recap: "Someday, people are going to brag that they worked with you" Sonia Saraiya
"Game of Thrones" writer, Sansa and Ramsay speak out about horrifying rape scene: "I kinda loved it" Anna Silman
Jon Stewart vs Sean Hannity: We all know who the real "sanctimonious jackass" is Sophia A. McClennen
Paul Krugman drops an epic truth-bomb on Jeb Bush. Marco Rubio and the Iraq war debate Salon Staff
Stephen Colbert warns graduates: Fight racism and climate change or prepare to live in a "Mad Max"-style dystopia Colin Gorenstein
Joyce Carol Oates tweets epic dissatisfaction with "Mad Men" finale Salon Staff
Twitter can\'t believe what happened on the series finale of "Mad Men" either Scott Eric Kaufman
New report accuses Bill O\'Reilly of domestic violence against ex-wife Colin Gorenstein
"Mad Men\'s" ambiguous finale earns ambiguous reviews: What the web\'s smartest voices are saying Salon Staff
This is the only way "Mad Men" should end James Othmer
Marco Rubio\'s insane "Mad Men" tweet: His takeaway was that the 20th century was awesome Salon Staff
Sawyer Fredericks Wins \'The Voice\' Season Eight
Veruca Salt\'s Original Lineup Preps New Album \'Ghost Notes\'
Brad Paisley to Open for the Rolling Stones in Nashville
Jay Z \'Completely Used Me,\' Artist Marina Abramovic Claims
Florence and the Machine Learn to Dance Like \'Delilah\' on New Song
An Unforgettable Look At Cher Through The Years, In Honor Of The Star\'s 69th Birthday
The Cannes Diaries 2015: The DPA Gifting Lounge Top Ten Must Haves
SALON ® is registered in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office as a trademark of Salon Media Group Inc.
read more
साइन इन करें या शामिल होइए फैन्पॉप पेअपनी टिप्पणी जोड़ने के लिए