Because he has to live a life of regret.

luke had it hard as a kid with the whole dan and nate thing!!! but peyton has 2 dead moms and a dad whos never around!!!

why peyton she fine .... lol nathan poor guy

Peyton deffo her life is so screwed

gotta go with marissa on this one.. since she died and all.

she had 2 dead moms she has a dad thats out to sea.
And physco Derek so i think that Peyton had it worse.

Why are there O.C options on OTH picks???

her life is shit!

lol just wondering if ne1 wud go 4 the o.c options thts all. I wud hv gone with peyton personally then probably nathan then luke

peyton has gone through 2 dead moms
she never sees her dad
she ahd a stalker
not to mentions he ahs to see the guy she loves is engaged to a different girl

i like peyton but she has gone through a lot people dying in her life and people almost dying stalker finding out she had a brother and he was in the army or w/e and seeing her true love engaged to tht bitch lindsay

luke had a hard time w/dan.nate had to live through hell w/all the crap dan has done and w/debs rehab bull, and gettin used 2 luke.brookes had it bad w/her oh-so-lovin--not--witch of a mother.
BUT, PEYTON WINS on this one, w/havin 2 moms die and constantly worryin bout her dad (who's never around) at sea an all. her life, besides bein really pretty, kewl, havin amazing ,and some really hot (nate, luke, jake) friends...besides all that her life sux ass!!!!!!!!! i luv her though!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

she died

i missed Lucas.. :(

or ryan