Brucasers: If Sophia played Peyton would आप like Leyton ? मतदान Results - वन ट्री हिल

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

वन ट्री हिल Brucasers: If Sophia played Peyton would आप like Leyton ?

69 fans picked:

Nope

64%

Yea probably

36%

3_ThePretender posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना

Make your pick! | next poll >>

22 comments

	xoheartinohioxo picked Nope: It has nothing to do with who portrays Peyton, I just don't ship them for numerous reasons. posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	BrookeGirl picked Yea probably: Possibly...one of the biggest reasons I ship BL is their AMAZING chemistry! posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	livelovelaugh picked Nope: i mite like them more coz there chemistry is amazing and they would look hot but the reason i dont ship leyton is because they are selfish and hurt people nothing to do with the actors posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	Cas_Cat_2 picked Nope: Even tho i love the Brucas chemistry more, Leyton also have it. It's not because of the chemistry or the actores. It's the storyline. posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	abs07 said: Right now Sophia is pulling a Peyton in the Brulian relationship (I'm scared of commitment) and it's anything but interesting. Sophia should stick to the witty corky side of serious relationships. Her whole crying and scared thing is getting old fast - she can't pull it off, lol. posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	livelovelaugh picked Nope: how is she pulling a peyton? peyton is commited to lucas and has never been scared to commiting yeh sophia should stick to the witty corky sides but the writers just cant let her be happy since shes been screwed over so many times posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	SelflessDesire picked Nope: Chad and Sophia do have amazing chemistry so it would help abit, but I still wouldn't ship them. I just don't like the Leyton story line or how they get together. posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	abs07 said: livelovelaugh I'm talking about Peyton from Season 1 with a "serious relationship" and Peyton from Season 5 with the "marriage". Everybody knows that half the time leyton's hurdles were caused by them. And I'm not saying that it's unrealistic that Brooke is scared of letting someone in, I just said that Sophia isn't pulling it off very well so I can't imagine her doing that a lot more as Peyton... posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना. last edited एक साल से अधिक पुराना

	jemgrl323 picked Nope: i really dont know!! i mean....PROBABLY not...cause i don't really like leyton's storyline...but the biggest reason i love brucas is their chemistry and how well the actors play off each other--- so maybe then i would. it's really hard to imagine though... but im guessing i wouldn't because i don't like what lucas's character does to peyton's character (i think she is much better off when she is not with him and he really brings her down and makes her act so dependent and weak) but i love hilarie burton-- so its not about liking sophia bush more than hilarie burton....i guess i would only like leyton a little better because i like how sophia bush connects with CMM more on screen than the way hilarie burton does with CMM on screen posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	tvfan5 picked Nope: I don't think I'd love Peyton if Hil didn't play her, honestly. She wouldn't be the same Peyton that she is now, therefore the Leyton story would be different. Thank god this isn't the case. posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना. last edited एक साल से अधिक पुराना

	saBRUCAS picked Nope: No I dont think so. But atleast they would have good chemistry so I might not hate them this much. Abs are you kidding me? Brooke's been like that since after s1. By "that" I mean scared of comitting. An she pulls it off amazingly. But seriously your saying that Sophia isnt pulling it off very well doesnt even matter cause you dont like anything about her. And please dont say you do cause you ahve always said something Anti-Brooke/Sophia in everything. And even if you say something nice you make sure to say something againt her as well. So, really, your opinion doest really matter here cause I'm preeettty sure every Brooke/Sophia fan thinks she is pulling this off VERY well. And I'm sure I'm going to get bombarded by all the LPers who agree with you. And they are probabaly going to say something like "I'm a Brooke fan, but I dont think she's pulling the "I'm scared to commit" think very well" Its so predictable. posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना. last edited एक साल से अधिक पुराना

	jamespotter picked Yea probably: omg haha i think that i would coz hopefully peyton wouldnt be so winney and brooks smile and charm lol love it posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	abs07 said: saBRUCAS you need to learn to read a comment properly before you reply: I never said Brooke was never put in a situation where she was afraid of committing. You don't need to "remind" me that she's been scared of committing post season 1 - I know that. I'm talking about Sophia playing Peyton's version of scared and how that side of Brooke that we see once and a while annoys me as it is. This whole Julian thing is already growing old fast IMO. Key word being MY opinion (Brooke/Brucas/Brulian fans have even said it too). I don't buy it. I know Brooke's fears are genuine but I'm officially annoyed. I think Hilarie did a better job at playing that kind of role. So the thought of Peyton being played by Sophia makes me wanna pull my hair out. It's the flavor of Peyton that I'm talking about - a flavor I enjoy only from Hilarie (except season 2 that was just ridiculous but I've already mentioned that a thousand times in the past). I can only tolerate that side of Sophia in doses - never in general. Her whole insecure thing in season 2 was annoying - warranted, but annoying. I just didn't like that side of Sophia's acting. The only time she did that well was in the 309 reunion. But in general I just don't care for that side of her. I would LOVE it if Sophia would always approach the fear with a tough front but she still let the audience know she's just scared (but she rarely does). Whiney brooke never did it for me. She pulls off the witty bubbly "Brooke" better than anyone even though I don't like Brooke. Something Hilarie doesn't pull off nearly as well (I can only take that side of Hilarie's acting in doses as well). So don't you say I don't like anything about Sophia cause my comments have always been directed toward Brooke when I've had criticism,not sophia (there are very few occasions where I've EVER criticized Sophia because she's a very solid actress overall and I've said that many times in fanpop throughout the years). I criticize everyone's acting when it's not their best - yes even my "precious" Leyton/Chilarie. This season may not be Sophia's peak (Season 3 was iMO), but I think she's an amazing actress in general so don't throw out accusations that you know nothing about. You obviously haven't read all my comments because I've praised Sophia's performances in many picks so I'll say this politely - back off. posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना. last edited एक साल से अधिक पुराना

	jennifer_02 picked Nope: no because it owuld be the exact same storyline just different people playing them posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	livexthexlife92 picked Nope: no i love brucas for their story and their ahmazing scenes and classic moments. i love hilarie but i still dislike peyton. but ehh idk with soph playing peyton atleast leyton would have awsome chemistry. but im pretty sure id still be a brucas fan :) posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	livexthexlife92 picked Nope: lol oh and amen to that saBrucas. posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	alex_sandra picked Yea probably: I'm sure that Yes! We've just simple got used to see Hilarie as Peyton and Sophia aka Brooke, but if S.B. played P.Sawyer and H.B. played B.Davis from the beginning I'm sure that all the Leyton's fans were fans of Sophia-Peyton and all Brucas's were on Hilarie-Brooke side... posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	mollyx365 picked Yea probably: Probably b/c I like both couples for different reasons. So I`d still like both couples ... for different different reasons lol. Guys come on let`s be nice ;D posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	Shanice_12 picked Yea probably: I love Sophia as Brooke. And the character Peyton siuts Hilarie, so I love the way it is. And I love Leyton and I also loved Brucas! posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	leytonfaan_18 picked Nope: because it wouldnt be leyton then would it? posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	Lisiii picked Yea probably: Ummm...yes, probably ( : It's actually Sophia who fascinates me, her charme, her way to portray her characters and her amazing chemistry with almost everyone ^^ So I'm sure she'd portray Peyton in a very different way as well that's making me love Leyton. I don't have a problem with Hilarie, she's amazing and makes Peyton really interesting to watch...whiny but mostly interesting ^^ So it's hard to say. I love the way it is but I guess I'd love Leyton if Sophia played Peyton ( : posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.

	Drisina picked Nope: No because it's not of who plays it it's of how the character was. posted एक साल से अधिक पुराना.