None of them. I think this is the corniest storyline ever and if it`s true then she should adopt. Isn`t adoption like the style now?

Lucas obviously. i agree with kathiria its corny but cmon theyre growing up now theyre bound to have kids, and i just love brucas, and loathe mouth, eurgh

yes i agree with Kathiria here! why would she want to have a baby with someone who she doesnt want as a husband! it is obvious that she loves Mouth as a friend and there are no signs that she still loves Lucas and wants something more with him then friendship!

i heard that too and i think it's stupid. if I was lucas or mouth I wouldn't do it! and as brooke no way, that is a stupid storyline! othgirl_peyton said it best.

i still don't get why she'd want to have a baby with someone with a genetic heart disorder?!?!?!

Yesterday the new sides for episode 13 came out and there is a scene with Brooke and an adoption agency worker. If Brooke was going to have a kid it is going to be through adoption. I heard about the baby storyline and it was a foiler from what I have read recently.

well the spoiler i keep hearing is that brooke says she wants a family & thats why she came to tree hill, to ask mouth to help her raise their kid cuz hes her guy best friend! & it`s okay with me, imagine their cute little fam!

ew no if mouth and brooke start a family i will stop watching the show. Brooke needs to fall in love with somebody and the have a family but it def shouldn't be with mouth. i hate mouth

Lucas. They had a past and she should have a part of him. It seems weired but it makes sense.