I would love either Jay or Michael Cera in that role!!!! It's such an underappreciated movie that deserves some recognition!!! I reccomend it to any fans of 80s teen comedies or vampire comedies or just fans of the gendre!!! Look it up or find a way to see it cuz I think this movie needs a modern reboot:)

premise:

Jeremy Capello is a typica shy American teenager fighting with the usual problem of getting himself a girlfriend. Although he has someone interested in him, he has his eyes on his classmate Darla Blake, but she in turn is unnerved by his constant staring at her. Recently, Jeremy has been having some weird nightmares about a strange woman trying to seduce him, and later he actually encounters that woman named Nora, who makes an obvious invitation to him, while delivering groceries. His skirt-chasing best friend Ralph convinces him to take up the opportunity for a first erotic experience. But the encounter goes badly: first the woman bites him in the neck, then two strangers burst into the house, forcing Jeremy to run for his life. Next morning, Jeremy looks pale and does not feel well. Also, over the day he notices a strange man observing him. This man pops into his bedroom the very next night, introduces himself as Modoc and carefully attempts to relate to Jeremy that he is now a vampire. Jeremy of course is at first skeptical, to say the least, but a sudden aversion to garlic, an increasing sensitivity to sunlight and a craving for blood slowly convince him otherwise. His new vampire "life-style" hampers his attempts to start a relationship with Darla, who has finally become interested in him and also complicates matters with his best friend Ralph whose being mistaken for a creature of the night by two relentless vampire hunters; otherwise Jeremy begins to adapt to the minor impacts the change has brought to his life.

Sounds interesting though.