For me personally, it's his eyes. I प्यार everything there is about him, but his eyes are just really pretty to me. When I first saw him I was hooked. He was my first डिज़्नी character crush. He was different than any of the other villains at the time. That's probably why I प्यार अलादीन the movie in it's entirety. Also, he had a sense of humor, he was ambitious and smarter than the sultan. I would have married him and been his slave no problem.
He has this way about him. Maybe its the way he carries himself. Even though he is told "that he is so old" (really sultan?) he doesnt really care and believes he can get whatever he wants whenever he wants. Real villians have that mind set. Btw i totally think चमेली missed out lol