इस प्रश्न का उत्तर दो

हैरी पॉटर सवाल

If आप had a Choice would आप Change the story at all?

Explain Why या why not.
आप would also like to maybe add और to it या less. Tell me what आप would do if J.K came up to आप and कहा "What would आप change in the books?".

 spongebob105 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
next question »

हैरी पॉटर जवाब

BlackHound said:
It's not so much that I would change the story, because I think what JK did is truely epic, and I can't do better than what she did. I प्यार the story the way it is.

However...because I'm selfish, there are three individual changes I would make.

Hedwig's death I would rewrite so that it was the same in the book as it was in the film, because her film death was a और heroic one; she died defending Harry, rather than helpless in her cage. I wouldn't 'save' her, as terrible as that is to say, because her death (like so many others) was symbolic; it symbolized the end of Harry's childhood.

I would add a little bit of background on the relationship between Severus and Charity Burbage. They were friends, but we have no details (so we just have to wonder.) Her death could have had just a little और meaning.

I would, without hesitation या regret, switch फ्रेड with Percy.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Nice. I agree with आप about the movie version of Hedwig. But she might go into और detail about Burbage in her Encyclopedia. :)
Superstar12225 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
I don't think Percy dying instead of फ्रेड would have had the same impact. So as much as I loved फ्रेड I'd leave that the same. If they were going to do anything with Percy I would have liked to see him become a death eater, to have a member of a family as good as the weasleys शामिल होइए Voldermort would have made a great storyline in my opinion
D_J267 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
u r toally right!!
moviefreak12 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
Andressa_Weld said:
Harry would marry Luna, and Neville would marry Ginny.
select as best answer
 Harry would marry Luna, and Neville would marry Ginny.
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
I ship Neville ginny too! Harry luna is सेकंड to harry hermione
emilykuru posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
I agree with आप bout luna and harry cuz I think their really cute whenever their near eachother and just talkin
avjimenez posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
Oh thanks guys
Andressa_Weld posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
TsuQ said:
There are several things I would change about the book series.

I would undo all the editing done to try to make the पुस्तकें short. I don't mind पढ़ना 800 page books, and for a good series like HP, I could go for a 1200+ page book as long as the quality holds. Book 7 in particular was too short... The plot was almost falling apart at the seams to support brevity. I'd have to see what the new पुस्तकें read but there are a couple और changes I'd make regardless.

Another change I would make, although it may not be popular, is to have Harry and Voldemort both die when Harry finally faces him head on. I think that considering the circumstances in the story, it's only appropriate. The 'work around' to allow Harry to survive is at best, troublesome from a logical perspective.

There are some other things I'd like to see in book 6 and 7 especially, a strong redemption Draco side plot, changing some pairings, avoid the death of some characters I like, but those are the two main changes that I think would improve the story.

select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
Perfidia said:
Only one thing: have Bellatrix killed द्वारा Minerva McGonagall या Flitwick because that would be just fair. Bellatrix entertained us a lot through the last four पुस्तकें and she shouldn't die द्वारा the hands of unworthy Mrs.Weasly...she deserves a duel with an equally skilled person that would not make her death so embarrassing!!
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
I realize that most women who हलके पीले रंग का, फॉन, हलके पीले रंग over या idolize Bellatrix don't get the symbolism of her meeting her end at Molly's hands. Bellatrix is the very antithisis of Molly, indeed, of any Mother-figure. It makes sense to me that JK wrote it that way. Hell, I'm just glad Lestrange died.
BlackHound posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
I agree with Black Hound. It's Bellatrix "If I had sons, I would be glad to give them up to the service of the Dark Lord" Lestrange vs. Molly "Not my daughter, आप bitch!" Weasley.
Pensieve_Seeker posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
I still dislike her because Bellatrix was one of my favourite characters...but true, it changed the image of Molly a lot
Perfidia posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
emilykuru said:
I like most of what is written.But here is what I will change:

1.Hedwig should ave died like in the movie
2.Percy inplace of Fred
3.Tonks should have killed Bellatrix (avenging Sirius)
4.Harry and Hermione should get together (dont attack me for that one!)
5.Dobby shouldnt have died.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Yeah, it would have been great if टॉंक्स could have done that, but Bellatrix had killed her first.
BlackHound posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
^lol yeah...
rapunzeleah123 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
yeah but I wish she hadnt done that.
emilykuru posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
Yeah, but if Percy died, I will get thrown out of the cinema for trying to throw a party. It seems better to get kicked out for crying.
RavenclawRocks posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
jadore_renard said:
There are many things I would have liked to change directly after पढ़ना the seventh book, such as टॉंक्स and Lupin's deaths as well as Moody's, but then I realised that changing that would have made everything less real. There would have been no sense of loss and the fact that they won in the end wouldn't have been nearly as sweet.

The one thing I'd really like to change is who Neville and Luna ended up marrying (Sorry Hannah D:) I'm a huge Luneville प्रशंसक and really wish they'd of ended up together ^^; Seriously, I wouldn't have minded if Ginny and Harry didn't get together. Harry could have ended up alone and I'd of been pleased if Luna and Neville had gotten married.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
I would definately have been happy to see Luna and Neville together.
BlackHound posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
Me too
rapunzeleah123 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
LadyNottingham said:
Severus would not have died. No way !

Percy would have met the Pearly Gates instead of Fred.

Moody would not have died either. I would have gladly sacrified Mundungus Fletcher instead.

But that's just me. Fortunately, we still have fanfic लेखन to keep these people alive if we want to.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Percy, believe me, would NOT see the pearly gates XD
rapunzeleah123 posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
Yes, I agree about Severus, आप know I do LN, but if I made that rewrite, then no one on Our Side would have died. ;) :p
BlackHound posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
Yes, I know, BH, we प्यार them too much. I forgot Dobby - he vould not have died either. But there again, the saga would not have been what it is... well... maybe... dunno...
LadyNottingham posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
AllTheWorld said:
Not at all, but I would change some details.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
Narusasu4EVER said:
Bellatrix would not be dead,but instead molly would be killed द्वारा her,also Voldemort would be the one to survive at the end!!Death Eaters would have take over the world and that's all!!!If i didn't change the end of the battle,i would sure change the epilogue,Harry and Draco would end up together!!!!Ginny would have died!!!!Slash FTW!!!
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
bri-marie said:
I think I would. For starters I would have switched फ्रेड with another Weasley (probably Ron या Bill).

I would have changed the way Mad-Eye died (or just not killed him at all). I don't think it did justice for the man at all. I also would have made Hedwig's death और similar to how it was in the movies.

I would not have killed Severus. I honestly think there would be और redemption in his characterization द्वारा giving him another chance than having Harry name his kid after him.

I would not have killed Lupin and Tonks. I think killing both of them off is just way to similar to Harry's story.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
I'm with you, especially about Severus. He really needed a सेकंड chance. Teddy Lupin, the अगला Harry ?
LadyNottingham posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
That's what I was thinking. I mean, Teddy wouldn't be abused like Harry, but he'd still be famous (the son of two war heroes?) and an orphan.
bri-marie posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
*
And the godson of the Boy-Who-Lived-and-Managed-to-Get-Rid-of-You-Know-Who !
LadyNottingham posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
Ms_Mea said:
Hmm, the story was amazing as it was, but there are a couple of things I would've changed:
-Ginny would've moved on after Harry broke up with her and they both would've ended up with someone else
-Dramione या Harmony would've happened <3
-Fred, टॉंक्स and Remus DEFINITELY wouldn't have died
And Ron probably would've been nicer to hermione during the first couple of books...
But that's just me :)
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
*
Harmione! I प्यार Harry/Hermione together!
emilykuru posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना
bellatrix114 said:
yes i would have bellatrix live of course :) x
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
moviefreak12 said:
heck yah! i would have made draco become reaaaally bad!
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
NvrShoutNvr4evr said:
I would not change anything. I think the story is perfect. It's very informative and has a great story line. I would change the ending though. They end it द्वारा killing everyone and I would just leave the people alive and only kill Voldemort. या to give it a twist ending kill Harry. When they kill everyone it's really sad and I think they should keep them alive. Also I think they should have done और of a fast forward. They did a small one and told who they married but I think they should make a story out of it.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
LinaHarrow said:
Yes. I'd make Luneville canon.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
sylviakitty348 said:
फ्रेड and Dobby mainly. Anything else would have ruined the series! actually, i feel like Dobby had to die, even though im his biggest प्रशंसक EVER. the only thing i really wish hadn't happened was फ्रेड dying. it seemed kinda unnecessary. But if he had to die, at least give him a noble death, like diving in the line of आग to save a friend या family member. या dueling a powerful Death Eater या something. Not in an anonymous, totally बिना सोचे समझे explosion, where we dont even know who really killed him. I mean, i also agree with आप BlackHound, that i just cant imagine George without Fred. they were the inseperable duo, the mischevous mayhem makers, the Sirius/James of the new generation! i try to imagine one walking down the hallway without the other, and fail at it. I try to see George executing schemes and pranks, exploring secret tunnels, and inventing new merchandise for Weasley's Wizard Wheezes, द्वारा himself या with someone else, and fail at it. I पेड़ to imagine him existing without Fred, and fail at it. It really shocked and hurt me when he died. But moving on, i agree with the जवाब above me that i would have had Hedwig die the way she did in the movie, instead of the book. What really made me read, and then re-read, and then cry at that scene was because she was so helpless in defending herself. Because she was hit द्वारा a stray spell. I think that was the point though. everyone else, even Sirius, (R.I.P) i felt like their deaths actually contributed to the plotline and made an impact on the series and the characters, instead of just giving readers a sob scene, a little bit of action and suspense, and something to talk about, आप know?
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
Peverell_Twin said:
I would've made the Battle और 'epic' in scope.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
Lunalovely said:
Well no matter how much I want to prevent the deaths of characters, it would probably ruin the story.But I would change how they die:
Instead of dying द्वारा a बिना सोचे समझे explosion, I would have him die protecting George from a deatheater, don't care which one,and then before the whole battle ends, have George kill the deatheater who killed Fred.At least it gives Fred's death और honor.
Hedwig would have died how she does in the movie, protecting Harry. And टॉंक्स wouldn't have died along with Lupin. I mean, why did Rowling have to make Teddy an orphan?

Oh, and Luna would've ended up with Neville, and maybe Ginny wouldn't have been so obsessed with Harry in the beginning and she could have been a closer friend. I mean seriously, how many times do आप see them together in a group of friends, actually talking, not counting the DA.If that would've happened then I TOTALLY wouldnt have minded them marrying.
Oh and Ron would've been a little nicer to Hermione, not द्वारा alot cause I प्यार to see them bicker, but she deserves a little और kindness.
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
RavenclawRocks said:
The story is great now, but I would make a few minor changes.

Harry and Luna should of got together.

George should of had a girlfriend. I mean come on, him and फ्रेड were the most लोकप्रिय guys in the school. He should of got a girlfriend.

At least SOME Slytherins should of stayed to fight. It was kinda mean that they all left.

Ginny should of married Neville.

I should of married Draco (OK that one is a joke)
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
Prawls8612 said:
I would add several caracters and put और detail with caracters hardly ever mentioned in the series such as Charity Burbage. I would also save some caracters from their deaths in book 7 and switch it with some other people such as Percy because a major battle had to happen for him to realize that he was अभिनय like a git.
Other than that, I think it was a great series and any major change would've killed it. The series was just so EPIC!
Great job JKR!
select as best answer
posted एक साल  से अधिक पुराना 
next question »