No contest. Bellatrix is a better role model, that's for sure. xD

^^^ so true
she shows you that you should be loyal to what you belive is right

while bella s shows you that if you don't have a boyfriend to go jump of a cliff

^ Bella also shows you it's okay to be a crazy psycho...
and she also shows you being loyal is good, and this is harder than I thought, hmm... Oooh! She also teaches that you should never stop loving... hmmm.... no matter the pain that comes with it...
I fail at defending Bellatrix. Even though she's my favorite villain. And I hate her. Don't ask...

I ♥ Bellatrix how can anyone choose the other Bella. Bellatrix is the best character ever. She teachs you to stand for what you belive in (even though she doesnt stand for a good cause) She also teaches you to be loyal and devoted. Bellatrix shows that you dont need a man to always save you from troble. Where as Bella completly depends on Edward or Jacob to save her useless a**. Bellatrix is a strong beautiful complex and brave character. Bella is flat and boring with no personality. Bellatrix also has a story behind her insanity... behind her motives love for Voldemort and fifteen hard years in Azkaban. Bella has barley any history it's all about her lusting for Eddykins and whats happening to her presently... barley any reasoning for what she does her only motive is "Edward Edward Edward OMG his sparkles are soooo sexy" *drools*. Bellatrix also shows that not everyone can be oh so perfect, shes crazy and evil and those are her flaws. Bellatrix is also very unique and shows that you can have your own sence of style and still look amazeing where as Bella shows that you should stick to the norm or you will be hated. Even though Bellatrix's insaity is a bad thjing it makes for good (dark) humor... and at least we know she has a personality. Bella is so blant, her insanity (seeing Edward evry where... putting herself in dangor to see him) is'nt very funny or healthy at all it's just weird. At least Bellatrix doesn't crucio herself to see Voldemort. People look at Bellatrix as if shes a bad role model, if you subtract the killing and sadistic nature of her you'll find that she's quite a good one (better then Bella any ways) as stated above she really shows that you should be loyal and devoted to your lover/friend/companion/ect.
Bella... not so much she abandons her friends for a guy she loves for all the wrong reasons (looks hotness ect.) It's never said why Bellatrix loves Voldemort so much but at lest we know (or it can be assumed) that she doesn't just like him because he's hot. Honestly I dont see what people see in Isabella Mary-Sue Swan.

^ wow thats long :P

☺ yup, because alot of people dont understand the complexity and greatness of Bellatrix Lestrange.

Zanhar, I applaud you. You almost - almost - changed my mind about Bellatrix (minus the killing and sadistic nature of her). That was wonderful. You deserve a potato. *holds one out*

Thank you ☺ *accepts the potato* Im glad to hear that I didnt just type all that for nothing lol.

Bella vs Bella is one of the few times I support Bella.

Bellatrix killed my favorite character. Bella Swan is just... -_- So I hate them both.

Whao a twihard actually hateing Bella? Amazeing.

Im glad you can support Bellatrix at least sometimes. ☺

Yes, sometimes. But I have those moments when I think Bellatrix is a good character and I'm being too harsh on her. But I just have to remember Nymphadora.... Hermione... Dobby.... Sirius.... :'(

She's one crazy mo-fo but she would kick Twi's Bella's little weak ass with one spell and a small point of the wand...

Well at least you're respectful about it, some users say things like: I hate Bellatrix shes a bitch and all her fans are too. and then one user constantly posted hate messages about me for likeing Bellatrix.

Are you talking to me about the respectful thing?
I don't know why someone would do that. I have a good friend on here who is a Bellatrix fan. And you're a very nice person. :) I just can't stand Bellatrix.... I hate HER, not Helena, not her fans, but Bellatrix.

Yes your respectful :)

Thanks nice to know Im nice. XD

Helena is amazeing alot of her fans are pretty nice.

I agree, Helena is amazing, an awesome actress, really pretty, and very talented. :)
But Bellatrix is none of those.

Helena seems like such a sweet friendly woman. She also seems fun and shes so herself, shes who she wants to be she doesnt try to impress the public and I appricate it.

Oooh, I love that about her as well! I would love to meet her... but not while she's acting as Bellatrix... there are SO many things I'd love to say/do to Bellatrix but not Helena.

I'd love to meet Helena too, espically when she's playing Bellatrix.

If I met Bellatrix, I know exactly what I'd say. I don't think I can stand it if I see Helena acting as Bellatrix and she yells, 'I killed Sirius Black, I killed Sirius Black!' It makes me want to murder her [Bellatrix, not Helena!]! >:( But Helena's acting is excellent...

I love Helena's acting.

Same!

She's so beautifully sarcotic (I have no idea if that describes her since I don't know what it means but I'm pretty sure it fits) and loyal. So much better than the other girl who's not good enough to deserve a name like Bella.

Mhm. : )

*Pulls hair out, slams head against wall, screams out in frustration*

I didn't wanna choose Bella Swan, but you put her against... HER.

You could choose to hate them both! I only pick Bellatrix in extreme conditions.... like this.

Oooh, I'll go change my answer. But still, Bella Swan didn't kill anyone. Bellatrix is a murderer no matter who you put her against.

You're right about that, Swan didn't kill anyone... But still, Isabella Swan! Sirius...ly... I think I should change my choice.
Because of Nymphadora, Sirius, Dobby.... because of Hermione, and Harry...
Order of the Phoenix, unite!

Im sticking to my answer Bellatrix is so much better then Mrs. Mary-Sue

Well... Bellatrix... is still a murderer, though. But I'll never pick Bella Swan, so this is the only option I've got. ^^
If there was only a choice between Bellatrix and Isabella, I either:
don't choose
choose Bellatrix.

Bellatrix for sure. She may be a crazy phsycotic bitch, but at least she's strong, and determined, and loyal. Bella Sue is the exact opposite, and is the most annoying and poorly written character in literature.

And also, Helena OWNS Stewart.

you should choose Bellatrix lol

Helena does own Stewert

I can agree with that part. Helena owns Stewart!

Stewert cant act

Yeah, I'm not much of a Twihard anymore. xD -late-

I'll agree with that, Stewart isn't acting, she's kind of just... There.

Oh that explains it (twihard)

Bellatrix is amazing. She's fun, strong, smart, etc. BEST HP CHATACTER!!

Bella Swan is just......god, words don't DESCRIBE her! Ugh.

^Hermione is the best HP character ever. We agreed on this.

I didnt XD KateKicksAss and I say Bellatrix is the best HP character.

well, zanhar, that's a LOOOONGGG comment !! LOL
you problably know which one is my fave right ?? *winks*

Bellatrix is kick ass !! If u can torture Dementor, Bellatrix will be in the first row LMAO

I know, I like makeing long comments. XD

Bellatrix has a more complex and colorful personality. Her character is awful, admiring, and amusing. She's smart, she's both twisted and childish, I can go on and on about how great she is.

^ totally