FOR TWILIGHT AND HARRY POTTER FANS!

For Twilight:

I read the book after watching the movie.
I like the book better because its like a never ending story. But, the movie its sort of hanging.

For Harry Potter:

I never read the पुस्तकें except one which is the Order Of The Phoenix. I didn't mind to finish it its because of its thickness. I agree the movie is better.

For HP I like the पुस्तकें better because they explain और and some of the फिल्में are kind of scary to me.
For Twilight, I don't like either but if I had to choose I'd say the movie because at least Jacob is hot (that's pretty much the only good thing about twilight to me)

Harry Potter:
The पुस्तकें because there is और to them, and give आप every little detail about Harry's world.

Twilight:
Even though the फिल्में were very cheesy and laughable, I liked them better because
a) They were good entertainment
b) They had और of a plot to it द्वारा दिखा रहा है a scene with James and his buddies in the beginning of the movie.

Harry Potter: Books, definitely. The फिल्में aren't bad, but they just don't go as deep into it as the पुस्तकें do.

Twilight (not a fan): Movies. They leave out(most of) the uneccesary details, so it's और interesting.

Ooh, ooh, and I did some research:
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (book): 309 pages
SS movie: 152 minutes

Twilight (book): 498 pages
Twilight (movie): 121 minutes

So as आप can see, Twilight the book was almost 200 pages longer than SS. And half an घंटा shorter. Because Twilight has hardly any plot!
(And yeah, yeah, I know font sizes in पुस्तकें may be different and all, but still . . .)

Harry Potter: The books, most definitely. The फिल्में were good until David Yates took over them.

Twilight: This is a tough one, but I'd probably have to say the पुस्तकें as well. The पुस्तकें were an epic fail, but the movie (I haven't seen NM yet) was a gigantic epic fail. They spelt "Quileute" as "Quillayute" on the side of the bus! Not even Yates can चोटी, शीर्ष that for stupidity.

Books, for both. Always the books. Has the movie really Ever been better than the book? Nope.

I like the पुस्तकें for both. The फिल्में will never have enough details या events that the पुस्तकें have. The पुस्तकें actually allow आप to feel like आप are in the different worlds with them. In movies, आप just watch them and can't really feel a connection.

I like the Twilight पुस्तकें better. In my opinion the फिल्में kind of sucked. Well the first one at least. The सेकंड one was better. The पुस्तकें are pretty much always better then the फिल्में though.

(TEAM HARRY POTTER)

That's tough. For the first three, I thought the फिल्में did the पुस्तकें justice. But for four and five, I felt that the फिल्में were better, because the पुस्तकें just dragged on and on...and nothing was really happening! It's like people stopped editing J.K. For six, I likee the book a whole lot better. In the movie, they kept adding scenes, and deleting some good ones.

for twilight definately the पुस्तकें cant stand the फिल्में but with Harry potter पुस्तकें and फिल्में i like equally

Twilight:

I cant really tell because I havent read the पुस्तकें because I dont even want to touch it. The फिल्में on the other hand makes me so sleepy, I ended up saying this to myself during the NEW MOON movie: "C'mon, the movie is not over yet,.. The climax will take place any moment-- What?! its over?! damn.."

Harry Potter:

I like the पुस्तकें more.. :))

i enjoy the book और than the movie, because आप can see what they are thinking, and that gives me a sense what type of person the character is, and i can imagine the scenes the way i want to, in a movie its made of some ones eleses imagination, and some times that bothers me because it ruins my picture and how i imagined a scene या person.

I´m a Harry Potter प्रशंसक and I like the पुस्तकें और than the movies, too. Of course the फिल्में are cool aswell, but how you´ve already said: good scenes are cut out या changed, आप can´t exactly see the thoughts and feelings of the persons, things do not look like आप imagined them, and so on.
But there´s one point that´s better in the movies: the background संगीत ;)

For Harry Potter: The books. They go और in-depth and I can imagine everything the way I want.

For Twilight: Haven't seen the movies.

For both series, I prefer the books.

The first four Harry Potter पुस्तकें were the first novels I ever read. I was only six at the time, and I've been an avid reader ever since. Of course, the films never live up to the books, especially the ones directed द्वारा *shudder* Yates, but they're still good.

For Twilight, आप have to make a hard decision. For some bizarre reason, I find Meyer's pill of a story easier to निगलना, निगल, निगल संकलन as a crappy book than a horrid movie. Probably because I don't have to put up with the world's ugliest, untalented, ridiculously overpaid cast in the history of the universe. Oh, and bad effects. I am an ILM fangirl (you don't get much nerdier than that), so when I see special effects as terrible as the ones in Twilight, I want to throw up.

So yes, पुस्तकें pwn movies, even those as shockingly bad as Twilight.

i dont like twilight but i must admit that the book is better and for harry potter i प्यार the book and the movie but the पुस्तकें are better the movie cuts out too much stuff

Harry Potter :
books, I read them before watching the फिल्में and I didn`t like that some scens weren`t included (although I know it would make movie too long)

Twilight:
I also read पुस्तकें before watching Twilight movie, but I can say both are stupid
still, movie has some good संगीत (muse, paramore)

Twilight:
The book. It sucked, but the part in the movie I saw was Bella saying "Where do आप sleep?" या something, and Edward कहा "I don't sleep." I just walked back up to my डेस्क and banged my head on it.

Harry Potter:
The book. Half of the फिल्में was Hedwig flying around with the Harry Potter theme song.

twilight: the movies, they didnt last as long. (sorry but it's true)

HP: the books, sorry but the फिल्में didn't live up to the books, but some of them are really good.

I definitely liked the पुस्तकें better, especially Eclipse.

The Twilight movie was संपूर्ण, कुल मिलाकर good, I think they could possibly have done a better job here and there. But I still like it :)

The New Moon movie I must say was my least favorite. It felt like they rushed the story, some of the events in the film that weren't in the book sort of ruined the plot, and....I just didn't like it as much.

The Eclipse movie is so far my favorite, mainly because of the action, Riley, Bree, Bryce's Victoria, and (last but no where NEAR least) Rosalie Hale and her story. =)
I loved the movie due to those reasons.

I did wish that they gave viewers a deeper look into Rosalie's past, but...you take what you're given, I guess. :/

Harry Potter: The book. The Harry Potter फिल्में suck, REALLY bad. The पुस्तकें are funny, they've got detail, they don't leave much out, and it's open for interpretation. It's an awesome piece of literature.

Twilight: The book. Why? Because the अभिनय is horrible.