andrew is hilarious!!!! he is amazing!!! he's my 5th favorite character in whole series!!! how can you NOT love him???

Andrew is one of my favourite Whedonverse characters. Him and Anya in seavon 7 = pricless

I don't think I every found him annoying. Sure I was anti Trio following the Katrina incident when it turned from being a minor issue to something seriously bad, but not anti-Andrew. Storyteller, the big board, and the oven mitts just make him awesome.

hes great and annoying!! i love him

he's harmless.

I have no idea what most of the fandom sees in him. He's far from the most offensive character, but nothing he's done more than halfway through season 7 justifies him still being relevant. To me, he's the Buffy equivalent of Peter Pettigrew. All he did was join up with a more powerful group. He always had an agenda.

He's pretty annoying and tbh I don't know why so many people seem to love him. I think the hype around him just makes him more annoying to me. I also don't like how people seem to forget he was a murderer just because he's funny.